Prevalence of Illegal Solid Waste Dumping Across a Differentiated Socio-Economic Gradient in Two Medium-Sized South African Towns

Abstract

Illegal solid waste dumping is a key urban sustainability challenge due to increased urbanisation and human consumption, but its prevalence and impacts across a socially differentiated gradient are seldom considered. We used street and off-street road surveys to examine the extent of illegal solid waste dumping across an income gradient in two medium-sized towns of Makhanda and Knysna in South Africa. We enumerated all dumpsites encountered in low- and high-income areas, recorded their GPS coordinates, and visually estimated size and composition using a standardised typology. We encountered 215 illegal solid waste dumpsites unevenly distributed by town (155 in Makhanda and 60 in Knysna) and income status, with the majority located in low-income areas compared to high-income areas. Most illegal solid waste dumpsites in low-income areas were small and located along roadsides and vacant plots. In both towns, illegal solid waste dumpsites were dominated by household and garden waste. The findings suggest that social differentiation matters in illegal solid waste dumping and should be factored into service provision strategies for ensuring environmental justice. We recommend that (i) municipalities should consider income heterogeneity in designing effective and equitable waste management plans, (ii) the national government should consider additional human and financial support to municipalities for efficient and equitable residential waste management, (iii) waste recycling at source (within households) should be mainstreamed in waste management strategies, and (iv) cleanup campaigns should be considered as a short-term solution to manage existing illegal solid waste dumpsites.