Predicting radiological severity of pulmonary tuberculosis in children: an assessment of the WHO-criteria and novel prediction scores on an individual participant dataset

Abstract

Background: The World Health Organization (WHO) recommends 4-month treatment for children with non-severe pulmonary tuberculosis, outlining eligibility criteria for settings with and without chest X-ray (CXR). We evaluated the diagnostic accuracy of the WHO eligibility criteria in settings without CXR (WHO-criteria) and developed clinical scores to support disease classification. Methods: Using data from an individual participant dataset (IPD; Decide TB) of children with confirmed/unconfirmed tuberculosis from four diagnostic studies (RaPaed-TB, Umoya, TB-Speed HIV, TB-Speed Decentralisation), we assessed the diagnostic accuracy of the WHO-criteria (with/without bacteriological testing) using expert CXR interpretation as a reference. We developed two multivariable logistic regression models with (Score 1) and without (Score 2) bacteriological testing, converted coefficients into integer scores with a threshold of >10 corresponding to a sensitivity ≥70%. Results: Of 2,383 children in the Decide TB IPD, 633 (26.6%) met the eligibility criteria for a 4-month regimen, of whom 116 (18.3%) had radiologically severe disease. With and without bacteriological testing, the WHO-criteria had sensitivities of 30.1% (95%CI: 20.3%-40.2%) and 21.7% (95%CI: 10.4%-34.5%), and specificities of 83.4% (95%CI: 80.2%-86.4%) and 81.9% (95%CI: 78.8%-84.9%), respectively. Score 1 and Score 2 had sensitivities of 41.1% (95%CI: 32.4%-49.5%) and 30.9% (95%CI: 22.6%-40.4%), and specificities of 77.3% (95%CI: 73.6%-80.8%) and 83.0% (95%CI: 79.5%-86.3%), respectively. Using WHO-criteria, 91/116 (78.4%) and 105/116 (90.5%) of children were at risk of undertreatment, compared to 68/116 (58.6%) and 80/116 (68.9%) when using developed scores. Conclusions: Developed scores demonstrated better sensitivity than WHO-criteria, however, performance remained suboptimal. Implementing shorter antituberculosis regimens without CXR remains challenging in children.